By CALIXTE WONDJÈ, Ph.D.

Keywords: Anxiety Research; Causes of Foreign Language Anxiety; Correlation; Effects of Foreign Language Anxiety; EFL Speaking Anxiety; Ego Boundaries; Ego Permeability; Emotions; English as a Foreign Language; English as a Foreign Language (EFL) Learners; English Reading Anxiety; Fear of Failure; Fear of Making Mistakes; Foreign Language Anxiety; Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale; Individual Differences; L1 and L2 Identities and Performance; Language Anxiety; Language Learning; Other-oriented Perfectionism; Perfectionism; Self-confidence; Self-oriented; Socially Prescribed Perfectionist; Theoretical Framework; Turkish Learners.

Introduction

Learning a new language is an incredibly rewarding endeavor, but for many people, it can also be a deeply intimidating one. One of the most significant hurdles language learners face is the fear of making mistakes. This fear can have a profound impact on their ability to progress and succeed. In this article, we will explore how anxiety and the fear of failure affect language learners, examine the underlying psychological and social factors, and offer practical strategies to help overcome these barriers to learning.

The Fear of Making Mistakes: A Barrier to Progress

When learning a new language, making mistakes is not just inevitable, it is essential for growth. However, many learners struggle with anxiety and an overwhelming fear of failure, which can paralyze them and hinder their progress. Fear of making mistakes often leads to:

o Avoidance of Speaking: Many learners avoid speaking in the new language because they fear making errors in pronunciation, grammar, or vocabulary. This avoidance limits their opportunities to practice and reinforces the cycle of anxiety and fear.

o Perfectionism: The desire to speak or write “perfectly” can create unrealistic expectations, making learners reluctant to take risks or try new things. Perfectionism often stifles creativity and growth, as learners focus too much on correctness instead of fluency and communication.

o Self-Doubt: Fear of making mistakes often leads to negative self-talk and self-doubt. Learners may believe that they are not capable of mastering the language or that they are not “good enough,” which further exacerbates their anxiety.

o Emotional and Physiological Responses: The fear of failure can trigger physiological responses such as a racing heart, shallow breathing, sweating, and even nausea. This makes it even harder for learners to perform and can lead to a fear of social situations where language use is required.

o Stunted Learning: Fear of mistakes and failure can prevent learners from taking full advantage of immersive language experiences. Whether in conversation, watching movies in the target language, or reading books, learners may limit themselves to avoid feeling embarrassed or uncomfortable.

In the following pages, we will explore work that has been done in relation to the fear of failure of learners.

The Relationship Between Fear of Making Mistakes and Self-Confidence Level in Language Learning: A Review Article

This review made by Yiğit Salihoğlu¹ and titled, “The Relationship Between Fear of Making Mistakes and Self-Confidence Level in Language Learning: A Review Article”, explores the role of emotional factors, particularly the fear of making mistakes and self-confidence, in language learning. It challenges the traditional focus on cognitive factors, highlighting how emotions, such as fear and anxiety, significantly influence language acquisition. Emotions are seen as integral to motivation and behavior in learning, with the affective filter hypothesis (Krashen, 1982) suggesting that negative emotions like fear can act as barriers, while positive emotions facilitate learning.

Fear of making mistakes, particularly in speaking tasks, is a key emotional barrier, lowering self-confidence and increasing anxiety. This creates a cycle where learners avoid speaking, hindering their practice and progress. The paper emphasizes the need for strategies to reduce these negative emotions and boost self-confidence, underscoring the teacher’s role in creating a supportive environment.

Recommendations to reduce fear and build self-confidence include:

The Teacher’s Role

o Teachers can create a supportive classroom environment by adjusting seating arrangements to foster better eye contact and personal connections (Dörnyei & Scott, 1997).
o Constructive feedback should focus on progress, not perfection, to reduce fear of mistakes (Stevick, 1980).
o Teachers should be aware of students’ emotional needs and provide positive reinforcement to combat anxiety (Bao & Liu, 2021).
o Teachers can guide students through low-stakes activities, like peer reviews or pair/group work, to reduce anxiety and promote self-confidence (Young, 1991).
o Classroom Environment: Traditional classroom settings often contribute to anxiety, but approaches like Suggestopedia (Lozarov, 1978) advocate for relaxed, supportive learning environments, including the use of calming music to improve cognitive performance.

The fear of making mistakes can be mitigated through a non-threatening, encouraging classroom atmosphere that reduces stress and allows for error-based learning (Pânişoară, 2015; Krashen, 1982).

Self-Access Learning Centers

Noguchi (2015) highlighted the benefits of self-access centers, which reduce the fear of mistakes compared to traditional classrooms, offering a more personalized and less stressful setting for language learning.

Teacher’s Interventions

Studies suggest that teachers should actively intervene when students show signs of anxiety or lack of self-confidence. Positive interventions, such as validating mistakes as part of the learning process, can encourage students to overcome their fears (Ni, 2012; Hakim, 2019).

Peer Learning and Group Work

Pair and group activities can help students realize that making mistakes is a normal part of the learning process. These collaborative settings provide social support and reduce the pressure on individual learners (Young, 1991).

Social and Cultural Contexts

Students’ backgrounds and language proficiency levels influence their fear of mistakes. Teachers, parents, and communities need to collaborate to raise awareness of the importance of fostering self-confidence and reducing anxiety (Salman et al., 2022).

The paper examines the intricate relationship between emotions, self-confidence, and language learning, focusing on the impact of negative emotions, particularly the fear of making mistakes, on students’ language proficiency. Drawing on theories like Krashen’s Affective Filter, it highlights the interconnectedness of factors such as language proficiency, previous experiences, classroom environment, and sociocultural background. The paper argues that emotional factors cannot be ignored in language education, as they play a crucial role in shaping learners’ experiences and outcomes.

The study suggests that self-confidence is inversely related to fear of making mistakes, meaning higher self-confidence typically reduces anxiety and fear. The paper emphasizes the importance of understanding individual differences and how these influence students’ emotional responses to learning a new language. It also stresses the role of teachers in creating supportive environments that foster self-confidence and reduce fear, through strategies such as praise and relaxation techniques.

Furthermore, the paper calls for a deeper exploration of how institutional factors, government policies, and teacher training can help address these emotional challenges.

It suggests that more research is needed to understand the relationship between fear of mistakes and self-confidence, particularly through qualitative methods like interviews, and to develop practical solutions to enhance language learning experiences for all students.

The conclusion emphasizes the need for ongoing research to explore these dynamics further and provide actionable insights for educators and policymakers.

Fear of Failure Among Perfectionist Students

A study conducted by Ditto Prihadi and Abdul Aziz², explores how different dimensions of perfectionism contribute to fear of failure (FOF) among university students. It specifically examines whether self-oriented, other-oriented, or socially prescribed perfectionism is the primary predictor of FOF. Conducted with 351 undergraduate students from UCSI University in Malaysia, the research found that socially prescribed perfectionism — the belief that others expect perfection from them — was the only significant predictor of FOF. In contrast, self-oriented and other-oriented perfectionism did not significantly affect FOF. The results suggest that students are more likely to fear failure when they perceive external social pressures to be perfect.

Erikson’s theory of psychosocial development emphasizes the importance of success in each stage for social and cognitive growth, but it largely overlooks the role of failure, which can also be crucial in development. Fear of failure (FOF), a psychological phenomenon, can hinder progress, particularly in individuals with perfectionist tendencies. These individuals may avoid failure due to concerns about shame, disappointment, or negative impacts on their self-worth. FOF, as described by Atkinson (1987), can lead to maladaptive behaviors like avoidance and self-criticism, especially in academic settings.

Types of Fear of Failure

The study identifies five types of FOF: fear of public humiliation, concern about personal worth, fear of losing attention or affection, anxiety about future failure, and worry about disappointing others. These fears often prevent individuals from taking risks, affecting their academic and social development, especially in university students. The study examines how different forms of perfectionism (self-oriented, other-oriented, and socially prescribed) contribute to FOF, with a focus on how perfectionism may exacerbate this fear and hinder personal growth.

Fear of Failure Influencing Factors

FOF is influenced by several factors:

o Responsibility: A strong sense of responsibility can increase FOF, as individuals see failure as more consequential.
o Personality: Traits like perfectionism are linked to heightened FOF.
o Adolescence and Motivation: Motivational factors during adolescence, such as the drive for achievement, contribute to increased FOF.

Types of Perfectionism

The study explores three types of perfectionism:

o Self-oriented perfectionism (SOP): Unrealistic self-expectations, often adaptive but can lead to high stress.
o Other-oriented perfectionism (OOP): Imposing unrealistic expectations on others, typically maladaptive.
o Socially prescribed perfectionism (SPP): Belief that others expect perfection, often linked to maladaptive behaviors.

Fear of Failure Impacts on Students

FOF impacts students in various ways:

o Academic Impact: It negatively affects motivation, learning behaviors, self-esteem, and can lead to procrastination.
o Emotional and Social Effects: It contributes to stress, anxiety, and social withdrawal, particularly among perfectionistic individuals in Generation Z.

Using Protection Motivation Theory (PMT), the study explains that individuals assess threats (e.g., academic failure) and react with either adaptive or maladaptive behaviors. FOF is seen as a natural response to perceived threats, particularly when failure leads to negative social or mental health outcomes.

The study also explores how perfectionism, especially socially prescribed perfectionism, correlates with FOF. Self-oriented perfectionism was less associated with FOF, while other-oriented and socially prescribed perfectionism were stronger predictors. These findings suggest that societal expectations contribute significantly to FOF. The study calls for a shift in educational approaches to prioritize personal growth over rigid standards of success.

In conclusion, FOF is closely linked to perfectionism, particularly socially prescribed perfectionism. The study highlights the need for future research to explore the relationship between perfectionism and FOF more deeply, using objective and longitudinal measures. It advocates for developing coping strategies that support student well-being and academic success.

The Psychological Roots of Fear in Language Learning

To understand why the fear of mistakes is so pervasive among language learners, we must consider the psychological and social factors at play.

Cognitive Distortions

Cognitive distortions are irrational or biased ways of thinking that can contribute to anxiety and fear. Some common cognitive distortions that language learners may experience include:

o Catastrophizing: Expecting the worst-case scenario, such as if making a mistake will lead to complete failure or humiliation.
o All-or-Nothing Thinking: Believing that anything less than perfect performance is a failure. For instance, if a learner stumbles on one word or mispronounces a phrase, they may feel as if their entire effort is worthless.
o Personalization: Over-identifying with mistakes by thinking that errors reflect personal inadequacy or incompetence.

These distorted thoughts can increase anxiety and prevent learners from taking the necessary steps to overcome their fears.

Fear of Judgment and Social Rejection

The fear of being judged by others is another powerful psychological factor. Language learners, especially beginners, often worry that others will ridicule them for their mistakes, leading to social embarrassment. In many cultures, there is a strong emphasis on correctness, especially when speaking a second language. This social pressure can make learners feel self-conscious and reluctant to speak up or engage in conversation, which only reinforces their fear.

Perfectionism

As mentioned earlier, perfectionism is a common trait among language learners. Perfectionists tend to set unrealistically high standards for themselves, which can result in feelings of frustration and inadequacy when they inevitably fall short. This perfectionist mindset can hinder the natural, experimental process of language learning, where mistakes are an integral part of the journey.

Lack of Self-Compassion

Many language learners are extremely hard on themselves, often because they equate making mistakes with failure. This lack of self-compassion can exacerbate feelings of shame and anxiety. Instead of viewing mistakes as learning opportunities, learners may internalize them as evidence of their inability to succeed, creating a negative feedback loop.

A Review of Horwitz and Cope’s Theory of Foreign Language Anxiety and the Challenges to the Theory

In a paper titled A Review of Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope’s Theory of Foreign Language Anxiety and the Challenges to the Theory Tran Thi Thu Trang³, the author, reviews the theory of foreign language anxiety proposed by Horwitz, Horwitz, and Cope, which has become a foundational framework in the study of language learning anxiety. The author discusses foreign language anxiety (FLA), a specific type of anxiety experienced by learners in language learning contexts. The concept of academic anxiety, introduced by Cassady (2010), encompasses a range of anxieties faced by students across different disciplines, but FLA stands out as a unique form of anxiety tied specifically to learning and using a foreign language. Numerous studies have shown that FLA is a real phenomenon affecting many students, not just a theoretical construct.

Definitions of Foreign Language Anxiety

Several definitions of FLA are presented:

o Clement (1980) sees it as a complex psychological issue related to self-esteem and confidence.
o Young (1992) describes it as a complicated psychological phenomenon unique to language learning.
o MacIntyre and Gardner (1994) define it as tension and apprehension specifically related to speaking, listening, and learning a foreign language, or the negative emotional reactions students experience in such contexts.
o Zhang (2001) emphasizes the psychological tension felt by learners during language tasks.

The author highlights that Horwitz, Horwitz, and Cope (1986) were the first to conceptualize FLA as a distinct phenomenon separate from other anxieties, laying the foundation for much of the subsequent research in the field.

Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope’s Theory of Foreign Language Anxiety

Horwitz, Horwitz, and Cope’s (1986) theory of Foreign Language Anxiety (FLA) defines it as a unique form of anxiety tied specifically to the process of learning a foreign language. They argue that FLA is distinct from general classroom anxiety and arises from the challenges of self-expression and self-concept that language learning involves. Their theory highlights the specific, situational nature of FLA, suggesting that it is not just a transfer of general anxiety but a product of the foreign language learning context itself.

Prior to this theory, anxiety research struggled to establish a clear link between anxiety and language achievement. Horwitz et al. proposed that existing anxiety measures were too broad and lacked specificity to language learning. They developed the Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale (FLCAS) to measure FLA, which assesses communication apprehension, test anxiety, and fear of negative evaluation.

Their theory was supported by subsequent research, such as studies by MacIntyre and Gardner (1989), which showed that FLA is distinct from general anxiety and negatively impacts language learning. Studies also confirmed that FLA is specific to the language learning context and not easily explained by other types of anxiety (e.g., test or social anxiety). As a result, FLA became a widely accepted concept, with the FLCAS recognized as a reliable tool for measuring anxiety in language classrooms.

However, despite its widespread use, there has been ongoing debate about some aspects of the theory, including the complexity of anxiety types and the extent to which the FLCAS captures all dimensions of FLA. Nonetheless, Horwitz et al.’s work has played a crucial role in advancing the understanding of how anxiety affects second language acquisition.

Challenges to Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope’s Theory of Foreign Language Anxiety

The author also discusses four key challenges to the theory of Foreign Language Anxiety (FLA) proposed by Horwitz, Horwitz, and Cope. The challenges are related to (i) the direction of the causal relationship between FLA and language learning difficulties, (ii) the significance of FLA in language learning, (iii) the components of FLA, and (iv) the validity of the Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale (FLCAS).

Causal Relationship Between FLA and Language Learning Difficulties

Horwitz et al. suggested that FLA causes difficulties in language learning, but some researchers, such as Sparks and Ganschow, argue that anxiety may be a consequence of language learning difficulties rather than a cause. They contend that language anxiety is more likely to arise from students’ struggles with the language, rather than causing poor performance. However, supporters of Horwitz et al.’s theory, like MacIntyre, counter this by suggesting that anxiety can indeed be a causal factor that impairs language learning, even in students who know the material. This leads to the conclusion that FLA may both cause and result from language learning difficulties, depending on the situation.

Role of FLA in Language Learning

Horwitz et al. emphasize the significant impact of FLA on language achievement, but critics like Sparks and Ganschow question this, arguing that FLA is not the primary cause of learning problems. Instead, they propose the Linguistic Coding Differences Hypothesis (LCDH), suggesting that deficits in linguistic skills, not anxiety, are the root cause of difficulties in language learning. Some studies support this view, suggesting that anxiety might not be the main factor affecting language learning success.

Components of FLA

The text touches on differing perspectives about the specific components of FLA and how these relate to learning difficulties. While Horwitz et al. identify anxiety as an affective barrier, others argue that other factors, such as cognitive or skill-based issues, may be more important in explaining language learning challenges.

Validity of FLCAS

The Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale (FLCAS) developed by Horwitz et al. has been questioned by some researchers regarding its validity in accurately measuring the impact of anxiety on language learning. Critics suggest that the relationship between anxiety and language learning difficulties may not be as straightforward as FLCAS implies.

While there is evidence supporting the idea that FLA can significantly affect language learning, the relationship between anxiety and language learning difficulties is complex and may vary depending on individual circumstances. Researchers from different disciplines (e.g., cognitive psychology vs. learning disabilities) offer competing explanations, and the role of anxiety in language learning continues to be a debated issue.

For the third challenge, the author discusses the challenges and debates surrounding the concept of Foreign Language Anxiety (FLA), particularly in relation to the theory proposed by Horwitz et al. FLA includes three main components: communication apprehension, fear of negative evaluation, and test anxiety. However, the inclusion of test anxiety has been questioned by some researchers, who argue that it may be a general anxiety issue rather than specific to language learning. Studies, such as those by MacIntyre (1989) and Aida (1994), support the idea that test anxiety is not unique to the foreign language classroom, challenging its inclusion in the FLA model.

Further criticism has been directed at the Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale (FLCAS), developed by Horwitz et al., which some scholars like Sparks and Ganschow argue measures language proficiency rather than anxiety levels. They suggest that many of the FLCAS items assess language skills, such as comfort with speaking or memory for language, rather than anxiety. Despite these critiques, the FLCAS has become a widely used and reliable tool for measuring language anxiety.

The author concludes by recognizing that, Horwitz, Horwitz, and Cope’s theory of foreign language anxiety, despite challenges and ongoing debates, remains a distinct and complex type of anxiety, fundamentally different from other forms of anxiety. The theory has significantly influenced research in the field, though it is not without its flaws. While widely accepted, the theory may require revision, as foreign language anxiety remains a complex and debated topic that will likely continue to be a focus of study.

Foreign Language Anxiety: A Systematic Review

Ibrahim Naser Oteir and Abdullah Nijr Al-Otaibi⁴ made a systematic review of Foreign Language Anxiety published in Arab World English Journal. The increasing concern over foreign language learning highlights anxiety as a significant challenge for learners. Studies, including those by Horwitz et al. (1986), suggest that anxiety can undermine the language learning process. Many researchers agree that anxiety is a primary obstacle for English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners (Alrabai, 2014; Wu, 2010), and Horwitz (2001) states that most EFL learners experience varying levels of anxiety. The rise in anxious language learners is a growing concern, as noted by Horwitz and Young (1991). Anxiety can act as a barrier, preventing information from reaching the brain’s language acquisition areas (Krashen, 1982). Furthermore, anxiety can negatively impact learners’ enjoyment, performance, and overall achievement (MacIntyre, 1999; Riasati, 2011). Educators have also noted the detrimental effects of anxiety in language classes, with research by Von Worde (2003) indicating that it impedes language learning success. Given the negative consequences of anxiety on learners’ performance, further research into its causes and effects is necessary (Elaldi, 2016). The authors provide an extensive literature review on foreign language anxiety, exploring theoretical models, causes, and effects. The following is the summary of their review.

Definitions

Foreign language anxiety is defined in various ways in the literature. According to Ortega (2009), two key definitions are provided by Horwitz et al. (1986) and MacIntyre (1999). Horwitz et al. (1986) describe language anxiety as a complex set of self-perceptions, beliefs, feelings, and behaviors related to language learning in the classroom, stemming from the unique challenges of learning a new language. MacIntyre (1999) defines it as a feeling of stress, nervousness, emotional reaction, and worry associated with learning a second or foreign language.

Causes of Foreign Language Anxiety

The literature on foreign language anxiety identifies six main causes, which stem from three primary sources: the learner, the educator, and instructional practices. These causes include: 1) interpersonal and personal anxiety, 2) learners’ beliefs about language learning, 3) classroom procedures, 4) teacher-centered teaching methods, 5) teachers’ beliefs about language teaching, and 6) language exams. More recently, Luo (2012) identifies four primary sources of anxiety: the classroom atmosphere, learner attributes, the target language, and the language learning process itself.

Effects of Foreign Language Anxiety

Research on foreign language anxiety has shown that it negatively impacts language learning in several ways. These effects can be grouped into five main categories:

o Academically: High levels of language anxiety are linked to poor academic performance and lower language proficiency. Anxious students tend to perform worse and are more likely to drop out of language courses.
o Socially: Anxious students are less inclined to engage in communication, particularly in the foreign language, which can hinder their language practice and social interaction.
o Cognitively: Anxiety acts as an “affective filter,” blocking the learner’s ability to process and retain information, thus impeding language acquisition.
o Affectively: Anxiety negatively impacts other emotional factors like motivation and attitude towards learning, decreasing students’ overall enthusiasm and drive to study.
o Personally: Anxiety can cause physical and emotional symptoms, such as stress, forgetfulness, and nervousness, which can further reduce a student’s ability to learn.

Foreign language anxiety can have wide-ranging negative effects on students, affecting both their academic success and emotional well-being.

In conclusion, the review highlights that foreign language anxiety (FLA) is a significant challenge in language learning. A deeper understanding of its causes is crucial for developing effective strategies to alleviate it. While existing research has provided valuable insights, further studies are needed to validate previous findings. The review emphasizes that FLA negatively impacts language learning outcomes and points out the utility of the Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale (FLCAS) as a key tool for measuring anxiety levels in learners.

Speaking Anxiety Among Turkish EFL Learners: The Case at A State University

In a study titled “Speaking Anxiety Among Turkish EFL Learners: The Case at a State University”, Gökhan Öztürk and Nurdan Gürbüz⁵ explored the level, causes, and factors influencing foreign language speaking anxiety, as well as students’ perceptions of it, within a Turkish English as a Foreign Language (EFL) context. A total of 383 pre-intermediate students from an English preparatory program participated. Data were gathered using a questionnaire to assess speaking anxiety levels, followed by interviews with 19 students to gain deeper insights. The quantitative analysis showed that students generally experienced low levels of speaking anxiety. However, the study revealed that most students viewed speaking as a major source of anxiety, with key causes including pronunciation difficulties, fear of immediate questions, concerns about making mistakes, and fear of negative evaluation. The study concludes that foreign language speaking anxiety is a distinct phenomenon with unique causes, aspects, and effects on learners. The key elements of the study are as presented below.

Introduction

The study highlights the significant role human psychology plays in foreign language learning, emphasizing the impact of psychological factors on the learning process. Studies by various researchers (e.g., Chastain, 1975; Horwitz et al., 1986) demonstrate that affective factors such as self-esteem, empathy, introversion, and efficacy influence language acquisition. Research in this area often examines personality traits like motivation, risk-taking, extroversion, self-esteem, and anxiety. Anxiety, a key emotional factor, has been particularly studied for its positive or negative effects on language learning.

The study examined English as a Foreign Language (EFL) speaking anxiety among Turkish university students in an intensive language learning context. It found that most students experienced low levels of speaking anxiety overall. However, interviews revealed deeper insights into the factors contributing to anxiety, which can guide teachers in understanding and addressing these issues in speaking activities.

Key Findings

Key findings include:

o Speaking is perceived as a major source of anxiety for many students.
o EFL speaking anxiety can have a facilitative effect, encouraging students to be more cautious while speaking.
o Anxiety increases when students are unprepared or face immediate questions.
o This anxiety can lead to a lack of self-confidence and reluctance to speak in class.
o Causes of anxiety can be categorized into individual, environmental, and educational factors, with individual factors (like fear of making mistakes) being most prevalent.
o Worries about pronunciation and vocabulary mistakes contribute significantly to anxiety, with classroom mood and peer evaluation playing key roles.
o The study suggests practical recommendations for teachers:

• Allow students time to prepare before speaking tasks.
• Understand students’ individual backgrounds to tailor support.
• Foster a classroom atmosphere where mistakes are seen as learning opportunities.
• Minimize negative peer reactions to create a supportive environment.
• These insights help create a more comfortable and supportive classroom atmosphere, encouraging students to speak English with less anxiety.

Study on Correlation of Foreign Language Anxiety and English Reading Anxiety

In a paper titled Study on Correlation of Foreign Language Anxiety and English Reading Anxiety Qian Huang⁶defines anxiety and its classification, focusing on foreign language anxiety, particularly in the context of reading. It discusses the sources of foreign language anxiety for Chinese students, including lack of background knowledge, psychological factors (such as fear, poor reading habits, and low interest), and their impact on reading performance. The paper then presents four strategies to help students overcome reading anxiety and improve reading efficiency. It also offers teaching implications for English teachers to address this issue. Here’s a summary of the key points.

Definition of Anxiety

Anxiety has varying definitions depending on the perspective. From a psychological standpoint, it is often described as “a state of apprehension, a vague fear indirectly associated with an object” (Higard & Atkinson). In behavioral science, B.B. Wolman defines it as “a feeling of weakness and inability to cope with real or imagined threats.”

Language researchers recognize the close relationship between anxiety and foreign language learning. Spielberger (1983) defines it as “the subjective feeling of tension, apprehension, nervousness, and worry,” associated with the activation of the autonomic nervous system.

Anxiety is defined as a state of apprehension and fear, often associated with an inability to cope with perceived threats.

From a language learning perspective, it is defined as a feeling of nervousness, tension, and worry that can be triggered by language learning situations, particularly in a foreign language context.

Types of Anxiety

o Trait Anxiety: A stable tendency to experience anxiety across situations.
o State Anxiety: A temporary response to specific stress-inducing events.
o Situation-Specific Anxiety: Anxiety linked to a particular situation, such as public speaking or language tests.

Sources of Foreign Language Anxiety

o Personal Factors: Low self-esteem, competitiveness, and unrealistic beliefs about language learning can contribute to anxiety.
o Procedural Factors: Classroom practices like ineffective teaching methods, harsh error correction, and test anxiety.
o Cultural Factors: Cultural differences and fear of identity loss in a new cultural setting can heighten anxiety.

Understanding the sources of foreign language anxiety is crucial for improving language learning outcomes. By addressing these factors, teachers can develop more effective strategies that reduce anxiety and foster a more supportive, culturally sensitive learning environment.

Foreign Language Reading Anxiety (FLRA)

Reading is a critical cognitive process in language acquisition. Anxiety, particularly in reading, can impede comprehension and language proficiency.

Krashen’s Affective Filter Hypothesis suggests that emotions, including anxiety, can either hinder or facilitate language learning, depending on whether they create a “high” or “low” affective filter.

Study on Language Anxiety

The study on English language anxiety and reading anxiety (FLCAS and FLRAS) found that students with higher anxiety generally performed poorly in reading comprehension, while low anxiety was correlated with better performance. However, moderate anxiety sometimes had a positive effect.

Strategies to Overcome Reading Anxiety

o Building Faith in English Reading: Encouraging a positive attitude toward reading and promoting its importance in language learning.
o Developing Cross-Cultural Competence: Integrating cultural knowledge to reduce anxiety and confusion during reading.
o Encouraging Cooperative Learning: Using group learning to reduce individual pressure and boost confidence.
o Building Self-Confidence: Fostering self-esteem to help students approach reading challenges positively.

Implications for English Teaching

The research highlights the impact of reading anxiety on college students learning English as a foreign language. It emphasizes the urgent need for English teachers to understand and address this anxiety to improve teaching effectiveness. Key implications include:

o Identifying and Addressing Anxiety: Teachers should investigate and understand students’ anxiety levels, implementing strategies to reduce it. Anxiety affects reading performance, so alleviating it is essential for enhancing student confidence and success.
o Building Confidence: Since many students lack confidence in their reading due to high anxiety, teachers should create supportive environments, encourage students, and avoid criticism to help them become more self-assured.
o Normalizing Anxiety: Teachers should reassure students that reading anxiety is natural and common, helping them understand it is not shameful. By encouraging students and promoting a sense of success, teachers can boost students’ confidence and self-esteem.
o Developing Ideal Readers: Teachers should help students recognize the causes of their anxiety, foster a positive emotional state, and encourage peer discussions to share and manage anxieties, ultimately cultivating a more positive attitude toward foreign language reading.

In sum, the research advocates for a proactive approach in recognizing and addressing anxiety, supporting student confidence, and encouraging a positive learning environment to enhance reading proficiency.

Foreign Language Anxiety and Its Effect on Language Ego and Performance

The author of the thesis titled “Foreign Language Anxiety and Its Effect on Language Ego and Performance”, Kayleigh Jade Rippengale⁷, discusses the ongoing issue of foreign language anxiety (FLA) and its impact on language learners.

The Study Highlights

The study explores the role of FLA in second language acquisition, particularly how it influences language ego. It aims to connect the findings to recent research on identity in language learning. It examines the complex relationship between first (L1) and second (L2) language identities, challenges in speaking with an L2 identity, the limitations of language, and how anxiety impacts overall student performance.

The thesis examines the relationship between language anxiety, ego, and performance in language learning. It explores the inefficacy of traditional language-teaching methods (e.g., grammar and vocabulary-focused techniques), which often lead to high anxiety and poor student performance. The study identifies three primary causes of Foreign Language Anxiety (FLA): the educator, the learner, and teaching practices.

Language ego is a key factor, as learners often associate language learning with perfectionism, leading to low self-esteem and a lack of confidence. This can cause anxiety, especially when speaking, and negatively affect performance. When learners focus too much on their perceived shortcomings, it splits their attention between the task and self-doubt, making the learning experience unpleasant and decreasing motivation.

The thesis also highlights the role of cultural understanding in language learning. Learners’ lack of exposure to the target culture can lead to misinterpretations and further contribute to anxiety. The classroom environment is crucial; a supportive and constructive setting, where mistakes are handled with care, encourages students to take risks and improves their learning outcomes.

Additionally, the thesis differentiates between types of anxiety – state anxiety, situation-specific anxiety (language anxiety), and trait anxiety – emphasizing how these factors interfere with cognitive processes and hinder language acquisition. The study suggests that teachers need to recognize the affective factors in language learning and adjust their approach to reduce anxiety and foster a more effective learning environment.

The Findings

Case Studies and Questionnaires Results

The case studies and questionnaires emphasize the negative relationship between foreign language anxiety (FLA) and academic achievement, showing that low self-esteem often exacerbates anxiety, leading to poorer language performance. The research suggests that learners face challenges in developing a second identity in a target language, as the process of shifting from their first (L1) to their second (L2) language identity can create anxiety. Those with low self-esteem are more susceptible to this anxiety, which often hampers their performance.

The Language Ego

The concept of “language ego” highlights the difficulties in acquiring a second language, as learners must develop new ways of thinking. Both thick and thin ego boundaries can contribute to anxiety, but thick boundaries tend to result in stronger anxiety. Ideally, a mix of both boundaries leads to better language performance.

Language Anxiety Contributing Factors

Additionally, identity development in language acquisition is categorized into environmental, personality, and cognitive factors. These factors all contribute to language anxiety, with learners experiencing stress from judgment in the classroom (environmental), struggling with anxiety in public speaking (personality), and cognitive overload when processing too many factors simultaneously (cognitive).

Children Versus Adults: Who Is More Affected

The research also notes that children find it easier to acquire a second language compared to adults, due to the naturalness of language acquisition in childhood. In contrast, adults feel more anxious because they are more self-conscious, fear mistakes, and prefer rules over the example-based learning favored by children. This highlights the environmental, personality, and cognitive dimensions of language anxiety, which are more pronounced in adults than in children.

Findings from Students: Key Points

The findings from the student and lecturer questionnaires reveal several key points about language learning and anxiety. Many students struggle with speaking in class due to self-doubt and constant comparisons to others. Anxiety is prevalent not only in students who feel they lack natural language aptitude but also in those who excel, as peer reactions can create discomfort. Teachers also experience anxiety, which can affect their performance and stress levels. This is especially true for language instructors, who may feel pressure to be “perfect,” but perfectionism can be detrimental to both teaching and learning.

The analysis suggests that students’ comfort levels in class vary significantly, with beginners showing more anxiety than more experienced learners. Notably, students from different educational backgrounds, such as British and Polish students, exhibit different levels of familiarity and comfort with language learning. The British education system, where foreign language instruction typically starts later, contrasts with systems like Poland’s, where students are exposed to languages from an early age.

Interestingly, many students were unaware of Foreign Language Anxiety (FLA), though they quickly recognized it when explained, while all lecturers were familiar with it. This highlights the need to raise awareness of FLA in classrooms. Educators should address this issue early in students’ studies to help mitigate its impact on learning. Recognizing and discussing language anxiety could significantly improve students’ performance and willingness to participate in class.

In a questionnaire about language anxiety, 22 out of 25 students reported feeling nervous when speaking another language. The primary reasons for this anxiety were fear of making mistakes or being misunderstood (15 students), concerns about language ability (10 students), and fear of being judged by peers or lecturers (9 students). Some students noted that their anxiety varied based on the language they were speaking and how long they had been learning it. When asked about their feelings during conversation classes or oral exams, 21 out of 25 students said they were nervous, and 19 mentioned that their minds went blank under pressure. However, 15 students expressed confidence with the phrase “I can do this.”

The study highlighted key factors contributing to anxiety, such as peer perception and language ability. Many students also cited classroom issues, including the teaching methods and the fear of negative evaluation. One student mentioned feeling intimidated by more advanced classmates, and another noted that teachers often fail to correct grammatical mistakes, which slows down learning. Error correction, when done in front of the class, was found to increase self-consciousness.

Despite these challenges, 18 out of 25 students felt comfortable in the classroom. When asked about ways to improve the classroom environment, the most common suggestions were smaller groups, less pressure to speak, increased awareness of language anxiety, and more encouragement from lecturers.

Findings from Lecturers: Key Insights

The findings from the lecturers’ questionnaire highlight several key insights regarding language anxiety and motivation. However, it’s important to note that only six lecturers participated, so the results may not be fully conclusive.

o Signs of Anxious Students: All six lecturers reported recognizing signs of anxiety, such as reluctance to participate, discomfort, and poor attendance. These behaviors are common indicators of anxious students.

o Anxiety vs. Lack of Motivation: There is a strong overlap between anxiety and lack of motivation, as anxiety can cause a lack of motivation and vice versa. One lecturer emphasized that anxiety often hides beneath a lack of motivation, and students may feel discouraged, perceiving themselves as lazy or unmotivated, even when anxiety is the underlying cause. This supports the idea that distinguishing between the two is challenging.

o Causes of Language Anxiety: Fear of negative evaluation was identified by all six lecturers as the most likely cause of language anxiety, followed by test anxiety (5/6) and communication apprehension (4/6). These causes align with both lecturers’ and students’ perceptions of anxiety.

o Classroom Environment: All six lecturers agreed that the classroom environment contributes to anxiety, with one suggesting that error correction in front of peers should be avoided to reduce anxiety. Only one lecturer emphasized the role of the teacher in creating a supportive classroom environment.

o Encouraging Participation: Pair work was the most common strategy for encouraging anxious students to participate, with prompting and free participation also mentioned as helpful. However, lecturers warned that excessive reliance on prompting may create issues in exam situations, where no one is available to provide support.

o Lecturers’ Personal Experiences: Four out of six lecturers reported never experiencing language anxiety themselves, but some shared personal experiences of overcoming anxiety. One lecturer highlighted the importance of shifting negative thinking to positive, while another noted that accepting the commonality of nervousness helped them overcome anxiety.

The lecturers’ answers confirm the complex relationship between anxiety and motivation, the impact of classroom dynamics, and strategies for helping anxious students, all of which align with broader findings in the literature.

In Summary

The study discussed the challenges language learners face, particularly regarding language anxiety and the gradual improvement in their speaking confidence as they progress. As students move from beginner to advanced levels, they tend to overcome their fear of speaking, although not all learners experience this. The main barrier to confidence, as reported in the questionnaires, is the newness of the language, with limitations in vocabulary and grammar causing stress. The solution to this is continuous practice, as language acquisition is a long-term process with different rates of progress.

It is also noted that teaching methods focused solely on grammar and vocabulary are insufficient for achieving fluency and accuracy. Active communication and interactive learning strategies are crucial. Two teaching methods – Byram’s Direct Method, which emphasizes oral production in the target language, and the Zagreb method, which uses the first language to aid comprehension – have shown benefits. Teachers should be trained to create supportive environments, particularly to address language anxiety (FLA), with training courses available for educators to help them manage this challenge.

The study also highlighted that students’ self-perception plays a significant role in language learning. High-ability students who fail to perform well may suffer damage to their self-image, while those with positive self-perception tend to outperform their peers. Teachers need to be aware of these dynamics to better support learners and create a positive learning environment.

This research study examined the impact of language anxiety on the acquisition process of a second language, drawing on the works of Guiora, Beneviste, MacIntyre, and Horwitz. It highlighted how language anxiety negatively affects language ego and performance, particularly in language learning classrooms. However, the study suggested that language anxiety could be mitigated through supportive teaching methods. Raising awareness of language anxiety among students could encourage them to seek help, and providing teacher training could improve understanding and management of such anxiety.

The research explored the relationship between ego boundaries, language identity, and anxiety, particularly in oral skills. It stressed the importance of teachers monitoring classroom behavior and offering long-term solutions tailored to students’ needs. This study added to existing literature by focusing on foreign language anxiety (FLA) in UK higher education and suggested that both students and teachers need to address anxiety in language teaching. It proposed further exploration of how ego boundaries, gender, and autism may influence language anxiety, as well as the effects of L1 literacy on L2 proficiency and anxiety. Additionally, it pointed to the need for more research on language learning in the context of online education.

The Fear of Making Mistakes: A Barrier to Progress

The fear of making mistakes is a common psychological barrier that can hinder personal growth, creativity, and progress in various aspects of life. It manifests as a paralyzing fear of failure or a belief that mistakes reflect personal inadequacies, leading individuals to avoid taking risks or trying new things. This fear can be particularly prevalent in environments that emphasize perfectionism, high expectations, or rigid standards.

How the Fear of Making Mistakes Holds Us Back

The fear of making mistakes hold us back through the following behaviors:

o Stagnation: When we’re afraid to make mistakes, we often avoid stepping out of our comfort zones. This avoidance leads to stagnation, where we continue to perform within a limited scope, rather than pushing ourselves to grow, learn, and innovate. In essence, fear of mistakes can prevent us from gaining new experiences that are necessary for personal and professional development.

o Overthinking and Paralysis: This fear can lead to overthinking every decision, which may result in analysis paralysis. We become so fixated on avoiding errors that we struggle to make any decisions at all. This hesitation can delay progress or cause us to miss out on opportunities.

o Lack of Creativity: Creativity requires experimentation, trial and error, and the freedom to make mistakes. In environments that punish mistakes, individuals may become more focused on following the “right” path rather than exploring new ideas or taking creative risks. As a result, innovation is stifled, and growth is limited.

o Perfectionism: Many people tie their self-worth to achieving flawless outcomes. This perfectionistic mindset can be paralyzing because it reinforces the idea that any imperfection is a personal failure. As a result, individuals may procrastinate, avoiding tasks altogether to prevent the possibility of not meeting their own (often unattainable) standards.

o Loss of Confidence: A pattern of fearing mistakes can lead to a cycle of self-doubt. When mistakes inevitably happen, they can be magnified in the mind, reinforcing feelings of inadequacy. Over time, this erodes confidence, making it even harder to take risks in the future.

The Impact of Fear on Language Learning

The fear of making mistakes has a profound impact on the learning process. Some of the consequences of this fear include:

o Reduced Confidence: A learner who constantly fears making mistakes may lose confidence in their ability to speak or write in the new language. This lack of self-assurance can lead to missed opportunities for practice and hinder progress.

o Limited Exposure to Real-Life Language Use: To overcome the fear of mistakes, it is essential to practice in real-world situations. However, learners who are afraid of making mistakes may limit their exposure to the language in real-life contexts, such as in conversations, interactions with native speakers, or while watching media in the target language.

o Failure to Internalize Language Patterns: Making mistakes is essential for learning because it helps learners recognize areas for improvement and adjust their understanding. If learners are too afraid to make mistakes, they may fail to internalize important language patterns, which can slow their development.

o Stagnation: Fear of failure can cause learners to plateau, as they are reluctant to experiment with new words, structures, or expressions. This stagnation can be discouraging, leading to frustration and even giving up on the language learning process altogether.

The fear of making mistakes is a powerful force, but it doesn’t have to control us. By reframing mistakes as opportunities for growth, embracing imperfection, and fostering a growth mindset, we can break free from this fear and move forward with more confidence and resilience. Progress often requires us to stumble and learn from our failures, so we shouldn’t let the fear of mistakes stand in the way of our journey toward personal and professional fulfillment.

Overcoming the Fear of Making Mistakes: Strategies for Success

While the fear of making mistakes is a common challenge in language learning, it is not insurmountable. By changing the way learners view mistakes and taking practical steps to build confidence, it is possible to overcome this fear. Here are some strategies that can help:

Embrace a Growth Mindset

One of the most powerful ways to overcome the fear of mistakes is to adopt a growth mindset. Coined by psychologist Carol Dweck, a growth mindset is the belief that abilities and intelligence can be developed through effort and learning. Language learners with a growth mindset view mistakes as an essential part of the learning process rather than something to be feared. This shift in perspective can help learners approach challenges with curiosity and resilience.

o Focus on Progress, Not Perfection: Embrace small victories and incremental progress rather than obsessing overachieving perfection. Every mistake is an opportunity to learn and improve.

o Reframe Mistakes as Learning Opportunities: When a mistake occurs, instead of feeling embarrassed or discouraged, take it as a signal that you are pushing your limits and expanding your skills. Ask yourself: “What can I learn from this mistake?”

Normalize Mistakes in Language Learning

Mistakes should be viewed as a natural and even necessary part of the language learning process. Teachers and language learners alike need to create an environment where mistakes are accepted and not stigmatized.

o Celebrate Mistakes: Instead of hiding mistakes, celebrate them as a sign of progress. Acknowledge that making errors is a key part of the journey to fluency.

o Shift the Focus from Fluency to Communication: Rather than stressing perfect grammar or pronunciation, focus on communicating your message clearly. Language is ultimately about connection, and mistakes do not prevent communication from happening.

Practice Self-Compassion

Self-compassion involves treating yourself with the same kindness, concern, and support that you would offer a friend. Instead of being overly critical or harsh on yourself when you make a mistake, offer yourself understanding and encouragement.

o Avoid Negative Self-Talk: Replace self-critical thoughts such as “I’m not good enough” or “I’m a failure” with more supportive ones like “I’m doing my best,” or “I can learn from this mistake.”

o Focus on the Effort, Not the Outcome: Celebrate the effort you put into learning rather than fixating solely on the outcome. Every attempt is a step toward fluency.

Desensitize Yourself to the Fear of Speaking

One of the most effective ways to overcome the fear of speaking is simply to practice more. The more you expose yourself to the act of speaking, the less intimidating it becomes.

o Start Small: Begin by speaking in low-pressure situations, such as talking to yourself in the mirror, speaking with a friend or language exchange partner, or recording yourself.

o Gradual Exposure: Challenge yourself to speak with strangers or in real-world settings. The more you practice, the more comfortable you will become with making mistakes in front of others.

Seek Support and Build a Community

Having a support network can make a world of difference in overcoming the fear of making mistakes. Join a community of learners who are in the same boat or find a language exchange partner or tutor who is supportive and encouraging.

o Language Groups or Online Communities: Join online forums, social media groups, or local meetups where learners share their experiences, struggles, and successes. Knowing that others face similar challenges can help reduce feelings of isolation and fear.

o Work with Encouraging Teachers or Tutors: A supportive teacher who fosters a safe learning environment can help you feel more comfortable taking risks with the language. Look for someone who views mistakes as part of the learning process rather than something to be corrected immediately.

Relaxation and Breathing Techniques

When anxiety sets in, it can be hard to think clearly or speak confidently. Learning some simple relaxation techniques can help manage fear and reduce the physical symptoms of anxiety.

o Deep Breathing: Slow, deep breaths can help calm the nervous system and reduce feelings of panic. Before speaking, take a few moments to breathe deeply and focus on the present.

o Mindfulness: Mindfulness practices can help you stay grounded and focused, reducing the mental chatter that often accompanies anxiety. Engage in mindfulness exercises to improve your overall ability to stay calm and present.

Take Risks and Be Willing to Fail

Finally, the most important strategy for overcoming the fear of making mistakes is simply to embrace failure as part of the learning process. Language learning is inherently full of ups and downs, and the willingness to take risks and make mistakes is essential for growth.

o Get Comfortable with Being Uncomfortable: Push yourself to speak, write, and engage with the language, even if you feel unsure. The discomfort you feel is a sign that you’re pushing past your comfort zone, which is where true learning happens.

o Celebrate Courage, Not Just Success: Even if you make a mistake, celebrate the courage it took to try. Recognize that every effort brings you closer to your goal.

Conclusion

Overcoming the fear of making mistakes is a critical step in becoming a confident and successful language learner. By recognizing that mistakes are an integral part of the learning process and adopting strategies like embracing a growth mindset, practicing self-compassion, and seeking support, learners can gradually break free from the cycle of fear and anxiety. Ultimately, the key is to reframe mistakes not as failures but as opportunities for growth. With time, patience, and persistence, language learners can build the confidence they need to embrace the journey, knowing that mistakes are not obstacles, but stepping stones toward fluency.

Sources

1) Yiğit Salihoğlu. (March 2024). The Relationship Between Fear of Making Mistakes and Self-Confidence Level in Language Learning: A Review Article. Linguistic Forum – A Journal of Linguistics 6(1):88-101 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/383944252_The_Relationship_between_Fear_of_Making_Mistakes_and_Self-Confidence_Level_in_Language_Learning_A_Review_Article

2) Alethea Rachel Xi Ern Lee, Zahari Ishak, Mansor Abu Talib, Yi Ming Ho, Kususanto Ditto Prihadi, Abdul Aziz. (April 2024). Fear of failure among perfectionist students. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE) Vol. 13, No. 2, April 2024, pp. 643~651 ISSN: 2252-8822, DOI: 10.11591/ijere. v13i2.26296. https://ijere.iaescore.com/index.php/IJERE/article/view/26296

3) Tran Thi Thu Trang. (January 1, 2012). A Review of Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope’s Theory of Foreign Language Anxiety and the Challenges to the Theory. English Language Teaching. Canadian Centre of Science and Education. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1078777.pdf https://www.ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/elt/article/view/13878

4) Oteir, I. N., & Al-Otaibi, A. N. (2019). Foreign Language Anxiety: A Systematic Review. Arab World English Journal, 10 (3) 309-317. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.24093/awej/vol10no3.21

5) Öztürk, G., & Gürbüz, N. (2014). Speaking anxiety among Turkish EFL learners: The case at a state university. Journal of Language and Linguistic Studies, 10(1), 1-17. https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=f16047b02bc63fa530270046c14691dc1ffaad39

6) Qian Huang. (July 2012). Study on Correlation of Foreign Language Anxiety and English Reading Anxiety. Theory and Practice in Language Studies, Vol. 2, No. 7, pp. 1520-1525, July 2012. Doi:10.4304/tpls.2.7.1520-1525 https://www.academypublication.com/issues/past/tpls/vol02/07/27.pdf

7) Kayleigh Jade Rippengale. (2022). Foreign Language Anxiety and Its Effect on Language Ego and Performance. A Thesis Submitted by: Kayleigh Jade Rippengale [KAR29]. Research Supervisor: Dr Alex Mangold (Aberystwyth University Lecturer in German) 2nd Supervisor: Dr Jennifer Wood (Aberystwyth University Lecturer in Spanish) Department of: Modern Languages. https://pure.aber.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/62292766/Rippengale_Kayleigh.pdf

Other References Not Discussed In This Article

1) Anna Katharina Schaffner (May 9, 2023). How to Overcome Fear of Failure: Your Ultimate Guide. https://positivepsychology.com/fear-of-failure/. Anna Katharina Schaffner, Ph.D. Scientifically reviewed by Maike Neuhaus Ph.D. https://home.acceleratorsorg.com/resources/pdf/H05P85-PDF-ENG.PDF

2) Chiang, Y.-N. (2010). Foreign Language Anxiety and Student Interpreters’ Learning Outcomes: Implications for the Theory and Measurement of Interpretation Learning Anxiety. Meta, 55(3), 589–601. Volume 55, Number 3, September 2010. https://doi.org/10.7202/045079ar

3) Elaine K. Horwitz, Dolly J. Young. (1990). Language Anxiety: From Theory & Research to Classroom Implications 1st Edition. An edited compilation of articles in the field whose focus is to reduce anxiety in language learners. Text is appropriate for Graduate Teaching Methods course at all 4 Yr Schools. Publisher: Pearson; 1st edition (October 11, 1990). https://www.amazon.com/Language-Anxiety-Research-Classroom Implications/dp/0135234654

4) Marsala, Claire. (2020).  The Effects of Language Anxiety on Second Language Learners: A Literature Review. Student Research Submissions. 319. https://scholar.umw.edu/student_research/319

5) Tran Thi Thu Trang, Karen Moni and Richard B. Baldauf, Jr. (2019). Foreign language anxiety and its effects on students’ determination to study English: To abandon or not to abandon? https://tesol.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/TiC_S3_trang_tran.pdf